Thursday, February 19, 2009

Xbox 360 - F.E.A.R 2: Project Origin

F.E.A.R. 2: Project Origin by Warner Games

F.E.A.R. 2 is the sequel to F.E.A.R. The campaign mode is a straightforward first person shooter with some niceties. There is no way to change to third person mode. So, you never get to see your character. Note that there are no mirrors in this game (they're all broken), so you can't even see a reflection.

Story

This story appears to be a prequel type of sequel to F.E.A.R. This game, Project Origin, attempts to explain how F.E.A.R. all started. This wasn't done in the first game. The story to this game is reasonably long for a campaign based game (took me the better part of a week to get through it).  So, the length was about the same as Gears of War 2.  For a lot of reasons, it has similarities to The Darkness in the way the story unfolds... not so much the main character's abilities.

Game Play

This is a straight first person shooter. It doesn't do anything special when compared to most other shooters like Halo 3, The Darkness and BioShock. The niceties I mention earlier are primarily the weapons and mech vehicle you get to use in parts of the game. What's compelling about this game, though, is not the gameplay. It's the story.

Story

This game appears to be a prequel to the original F.E.A.R. The game appears to explain where Alma (the girl) game from and how she got to be where she is. While I generally like how the story unfolds, the ending is not satisfying as neither was F.E.A.R. If Warner Games decides to back another one of these titles, I hope that it's an actual sequel. One that finally ends the story of Alma.

The one thing I will say about F.E.A.R. is that even though the title implies something about fear, it is not terrifying or scary. Both games were suspenseful, yes, but not scary. So, don't go into this game expecting something to scare the pants off you. Gore, yes. Violence, yes. Suspense, Yes. Terror, no.

As you progress, you will find out that your character has a connection to Alma and also has some Telesthetic (whatever that is) abilities. But, the game never exploits this. You're stuck with standard projectile or technological weapons throughout the game. Instead, it seems that since you have this ability, you should be able to harness it for use towards the end of the game. Perhaps that the ability might be used to confuse the enemy or similar. Whatever the end result, it makes sense that they should let you use it on your enemies as you learn how to harness the power.

Controls

When you first begin playing this game, a warning screen pops up claiming that depending on the screen, the controls may not be able to keep up with the graphics on the screen. So, things may get out of sync.

In the 30 years I've been gaming, I've never seen a warning such as this. So, what was the point in it? That said, I will say that this game does appear to have some controller issues. But, it appears to be a programming issue and not a lag issue. By that I mean that the controller is unresponsive in places. So, you aim, pull the trigger, but the lag between when you pull the trigger is enough for the enemy to shoot you. This is quite frustrating. It almost seems that the game reacts to the trigger pull and forces a robot character to kill you instead of you killing it.

Tutorials

Tutorials are provided in the beginning to help get you to use the features you have available. So, the early levels force you to learn how to play the game. I'm mixed when it comes to tutorials, though. I find that they are usually too restrictive to be helpful and don't really help you learn the features. Just give me the gun (or whatever) and and let's move on. I'll learn as I go.

Checkpoints

This game is the type that uses checkpoint saves. You cannot save your place wherever you want. Instead, you have to rely on getting to a checkpoint. So. if your character dies, it will start up there. In some games, I find this can be a problem as sometimes checkpoints are too far apart. In this game, the checkpoints are close enough together that it wasn't overly problematic. There were a few places where I would have preferred closer checkpoints, but that was perhaps one or two places in the hundreds of checkpoints throughout the game.

Yes, I prefer to be able to save anywhere.. and I prefer that the game save full state information for full recovery, but that can also be an issue. When you restart the game from a checkpoint, it fills your health bar fully so this is at least one benefit of this system.

Health Pickups

This game basically requires you to find and apply health manually yourself which I am not a big fan of. There are two types of health pickups in this game: Immediate health replenish and med packs you can use at any time.

As you progress with this game, you will find less and less health (of any kind) throughout the levels. You also find, at most, one med pack per level at the end levels. This makes the game frustrating to complete because you end up with so little health your character is forever dying and restarting. This style of gaming is not challenging, it's just stupid.

Note that even though you may be carrying the maximum of 3 med packs, you must remember to apply the med packs yourself. The game won't do this for you. So, if you run out of health, your character dies (even though you carry 3 med packs). I found this part of the game the most stupid part. Just give me a feature to auto-apply health if it's there.

Weapons

Weapons are found plentifully throughout most levels as you eliminate enemies. So, you'll have plenty of ammo throughout the game, with the exception of one level. There is one level about 2/3 through the game where you will end completely out of ammo (because the enemies drop nothing). Head shots are your friend on this level.

Graphics

The graphics are reasonably well done. The texture maps on the environments are excellent. So, the terrain makes this game quite believable. There wasn't too much in way of glitching or slowdowns. Many of the later levels require strategic thinking (to conserve health and ammo) and still get to the next checkpoint. So, you don't go running into the level on a rampage and expect to get through the level. In most cases, you need to locate the enemies and use an attack plan to get rid of them one at a time. The best gun for this is the sniper rifle.

Audio

The audio sets a suspenseful mood. The music swells when enemies are near, so you can tell. It also subsides when you've cleared the level.

Overall

I liked the game reasonably well. The story was compelling enough, but the gameplay was a bit too standard for my tastes. If they had explored the mental abilities of the character and let him harness these powers as a weapon, I would have felt the game was much more complete. But, it didn't happen.

I also felt that the first F.E.A.R. game was slightly better than this one. This one seemed not as well done, even though the graphics looked good. In some ways, I felt that this game was a bit too much like The Darkness (without the creature powers). In the same way as you switched back and forth between real life and a dream realm, so does F.E.A.R. 2 in places. Unfortunately, you didn't get to play much in that realm. There was, in fact, only one level that played out in the dream realm. The rest of the game was played out in the game's real-life.

While the story was the best part, it didn't congeal the game fully and it also didn't end in a satisfactory way.. it was quite predictable.

Score

  • Sound: 8/10
  • Graphics: 8/10
  • Bugginess: 10/10 (Amazingly, no bugs or crashes)
  • Controls: 7/10
  • Bang-To-Buck: 1/10
  • Play Value: $15
  • Overall: 8/10 (no special gameplay, story was best part)

Monday, February 9, 2009

Xbox 360 - Quake Wars: Enemy Territory

Quake Wars: Enemy Territory by id

What's to say about this game? It's a straightforward level based shooter. It doesn't do anything special. Really!

Gameplay

There are two teams. The aliens and the soldiers. You are tasked to choose a class (type of soldier) to complete the campaign. You either win or lose.

Think of Quake Wars as a Capture The Flag style objective multiplayer gaming style. So, that means that you need to be the right class, then get to the objective spot to do whatever. So, you might be tasked to drive a vehicle to a specific location, place charges or hack something. In order to do this, you have to switch between classes.

On the other hand, the enemy doesn't seem to do that. All they do is run around trying to prevent you from that task. So, there's lots of dying.

The Good

If you like multi-player objective and team based play, you'll like Quake Wars. Other than that, there's not much else.

The Bad

Far too simplistic and too expensive for what it is. Each level has objectives, but your soldier character is constantly killed by the enemy. It takes too long waiting around for medics to fix you and even longer to respawn with a new wave of troops. The game's battling and running around is just like Wolfenstein (old school). The graphics aren't particularly spectacular and the movement is, again, old school.

When you win, all it does is say, GDF Wins. Not particularly thrilling. There's actually more hurrah when you lose than when you win.

Commentary

I was expecting more from this game. It's very simplistic in its design. It does what it does well, but still very simplistic. For me, this style of gaming has limited appeal and limited play value. This means that after a short while, I'll get bored and want to play something else. Note that I am not a big fan of multiplayer level based combat play. I'm just not up for running around on a play field hunted and killing. It's mindless gaming at its best... not my thing.

Score

  • Sound: 8/10
  • Graphics: 6/10 (way too old school and simplistic)
  • Bugginess: ??/10 (N/A)
  • Controls: 9/10 (control works well enough)
  • Bang-To-Buck: 4/10 (limited replay value)
  • Play Value: $15
  • Overall: 5.5/10 (simplistic, not enough to it, limited play value)

Friday, January 30, 2009

Xbox 360 - Spiderman: Web of Shadows

Spiderman: Web Of Shadows by Activision

At first, I discounted this game as a movie spinoff and didn't give it a second thought. Occasionally, I get desperate to find a new game and go search the used shelves. I had tried previous Spiderman titles and have been quite disappointed in the quality of the games. I am usually not a big fan of Activision titles either.  But, I had received a 30% off coupon for three used Xbox 360 titles from Gamestop and decided to give it a try.

First Impressions

At first, the game's premise seemed pretty straight forward. The graphics aren't blow you away awesome, but they are definitely passable for the type of game that it is. However, the one thing that you notice right away is the city is massive. The city is easily the size of the cities in Assassin's Creed. The crawling, webing and so forth you do in and around the buildings reminds me a lot of Assassin's Creed. The graphics on Assassin's Creed were far better, though.

But, that's where the similarities end between Assassin's Creed and Spiderman.

In Web of Shadows, you get to play as, obviously, Spiderman. This game is also set around the context of the final Spiderman film, but it doesn't follow the film. It has its own storyline (we'll come to that shortly). So, as a result, you also have the dark suit that you can don (or in the case of the game, toggle back and forth between). When you're Spiderman, you're good. When you're in the black suit, you're bad. So, certain things you do in the game gain you 'Red Points' and certain things gain you 'Black Points' depending on which suit you are wearing or which action you choose.

Audio

There is nothing spectucular about the audio. The web sound effects work quite well to make you feel like it's really shooting a web.

Controls

I was pleasantly surprised over the controls. Spiderman handles surprisingly well. The movement is sometimes a bit too fast (or, in some cases, uncontrollable). Overall, the controls do what they're supposed to do and are responsive to the button presses. When Spiderman swings from building to building, he handles very well. The only complaint I have here is that when it runs into a building, he doesn't want to get off of the web easily and generally falls to the ground. You can make him grab onto the building by pressing the jump or slide button. This will usually make him grab the building and start climbing.

Story

The story is that Spiderman is tasked to go around the city and right the wrongs and violence being committed. In this game, that means cleaning up the city of gangs among other tasks. Sometimes the gangs are on foot, somtimes they are in cars. So, as you're running around, you find gangs having gun fights and stop them. So, you have to use your Spidey powers to defeat these groups and gain you experience points.

Spidey Powers

You can climb buildings, spin webs (to swing, stop enemies and tie them up), spin blocking webs, sense enemies (see where they are) and run along the sides of buildings. As you level up, your combo skills go up.

Gameplay

The game is played basically as an extended tutorial. So, with each level you play, you get a new Spidey power. As you gain powers, you can do more. Each level basically makes you use that power to finish off the villain. Also, as you play, you can befriend both good and bad allies. These people can be called in to help you finish off fights.

As you progress, you will also need to help take injured civilians to the hospital or save them from exploding vehicles. If you fail to do this, you get awarded 'Black Points'. Saving them gives you 'Red Points'.

Leveling up

As you gain experience points, you gain purchasing power. You can then spend these points on increasing the effectiveness of your defensive and offensive powers. So, you can increase how fast you can shoot web bullets or how far you can throw them. You can increase your combo speed and skills as well. Both the red suit and black suit have their own upgrade paths and you can spend your points on either path you choose.

Save Points

You can save anywhere in this game. There are also some points at which it auto saves your progress (after you've completed an objective).

Objectives

These are like quests. You meet up with Cage (a good ally) who tasks you with doing certain things for him. As you complete the objectives he gives you, you gain more Spidey powers (and helps you level up).


Choosing a path

You get to choose Shadow Spiderman or Spiderman for your path (evil or good, respectively). The main problem with choosing a path is that you don't know the outcome until you choose it.  If the game designers had given a small visual of the outcomes, I'd be a little more inclined to know what to pick.  As it is, it's rather random because you don't know. 

Timed Moves

At the end of the boss levels, you are tasked to press the correct button at the correct time (like Guitar Hero).  While I understand why the designers do this, I don't like it.  Let me just finish the fight to completion in the fighting mode.  Or, alternatively, cut to a cut scene without these interactive timed sequences.  I don't really like the trial and error style of gaming.  Let's just move on without the trial and error gaming sequences.

Commentary

This game is reasonably well done, but towards the middle and end of the game, the graphics become exceedingly glitchy and the audio becomes very choppy. The save points make it easy to stop and start at convenient places, but there are only 3 saves. The controls work well to control Spiderman in most instances. The game gets a bit repetative in places due to the gang things you end up doing. However, the only reason it becomes repetative is if you choose to do the optional objectives. You can skip these and go right to the main objectives to keep the story going.

Overall

I like the game even though the graphics aren't perfect. The music works well enough. The game is reasonably fun and I have not run into any glitches or parts that are overly hard to get through. They did include health meters, so it's easy to see how much you have left, unlike Unreal engine based games.

Score
  • Sound: 9/10
  • Graphics: 8/10 (Spidey could look better when close)
  • Bugginess: 6/10 (crashed several times, very very very glitchy)
  • Controls: 8/10 (control works well enough, but could be better)
  • Bang-To-Buck: 4/10 (might be fun to replay)
  • Play Value: $25
  • Overall: 7.0/10 (Mostly fun, but gets repetitive in places)

Comments