Monday, January 12, 2009

iPod Touch / iPhone

iPod Touch / iPhone as a gaming platform

Gamezelot recently purchased an iPod Touch.  Because of the capabilities of the iPod touch (enough to rival the PSP), the potential for 3D iPod/iPhone games to become mainstream is significant.  There are already a number of games available through the iTunes store now.  With LucasArts release of The Force Unleashed, this may be turning the tide for the Touch to become a mainstream portable gaming platform.

Apple also needs to encourage gaming on this platform if they wish it to become a well rounded system and capable of competing with the PSP.  Otherwise, Apple may lose out to the Android platform where gaming may become more common place.

Gamezelot will be closely watching the gaming trends of the iPod and the iPhone.  It is on the brink of cracking portable gaming open.  But, only time will tell.

Feel free to leave a comment or send email to Brian at Gamezelot.

Friday, January 2, 2009

Xbox 360 - Too Human

Too Human

Vikings, Norse mythology, Valhalla, Helle... that's what Too Human is about. This game reminds me a little of the game Viking: Battle for Aasgard (Gamezelot reviewed this game in April 2008) in some ways. This game is basically a third person shooter with a leveling up system similar to Knights of the Old Republic.

Story

You're an Aesirian (not quite human) who is tasked to rid the Aesirian world of evil robots (and those who run them) and save the humans. Your name is Baldur the Aesirian. The story combines elements from a lot of different shooters, like Halo 3, Viking and Knights of the Old Republic into this tale. It combines all of these elements into a reasonably cohesive whole. The reasonably frequent cinematics endcap all quests so you know when they have both begun and ended.

Gameplay

The game designers decided to take a slightly different tack with this game's controls. Instead of using the buttons to fire, they opted to use both analog sticks in this process. The left stick controls the direction you are facing, the right stick controls the motion to the weapon or the direction of fire (depending on the currently brandished weapon). You have several different styles of weaponry to choose, such as pistols, swords, hammers (reminiscent of Thor), staves and rifles.

Just as FYI, I'm not overly fond of the double analog stick control system. It works, but I would have preferred buttons. The reason is simple. They use combos to get stronger attacks. It's next to impossible to perform proper combos using the analog stick. It's much more definitive to use buttons when creating combos.

Fighting

This is one of those kinds of games where every enemy focuses on your character even when there are other team members. There are two very annoying things about this style of gaming. First, the supplemental team member characters stand around and don't fire (even though they have a weapon and are supposed to). Second, your player character is completely barraged with enemies. Enemies after enemies. I understand they want to make it challenging, but hey where's the teamwork here? If it's supposed to be a team, then make it a team effort. Have the enemies focus in on the character that is closest to them instead of focusing on, chasing after and aiming at my character 100% of the time. There is no challenge in this, it's just stupid and lazy design.


Character Improvements

The character improvement screen is actually quite impressive. The leveling up system they have designed is quite extensive. There is quite a lot that can be done in these screens. In fact, there is so much to this that it's really overkill for this style of game. Basically, this level of third person shooter really doesn't need this depth of character-customizing sophistication. If the gameplay had expanded to a full out RPG, then this leveling system would have been much more useful.

It appears to me that the developers spent way too much time building out the character improvement area without much thought to how the game itself and the story of the game could be improved by such a system. Was is it wasted effort? I'm not sure, but I think a better questing system could have dramatically improved the quality of this title. I could easily see this character improvement system being sold off as an engine in itself to other game developers. It's really quite an achievement. Too bad the rest of the shooter didn't match up to that level.

Leveling up

As you progress through the game, you gain experience points by defeating enemies. At certain points you level up and gain skill points. Skill points are then allotted to a skill or class tree. These two trees expand your character's abilities.

The problem I have with leveling up, though, is that no matter how much you level up, you really gain no strength. The enemies are still far stronger than you. So, your weapons really do no more damage after leveling up than before. This is one of the main sore spots of this game.

Controls

The controls over the character is average to sub-standard. The main character controls are very stilted and old-style. There was really not as much effort put into the 3D character control system as there was in the quite impressive character leveling system. You can definitely tell where most of the development effort went (and it didn't go into the 3D character control system).

Camera

Every once in a while, a game comes along that can't figure out how to work the camera. Too Human is one of those games. The camera in this game tends to be all over the place. Sometimes it faces the direction of the character, sometimes it faces in some random direction or to the side of the character. So, at key times when you're trying to focus on an enemy, the camera decides to readjust to the side or the front of the character and focus away from the enemy. So, instead of seeing the enemy, you're watching your character run.

These camera problems really should be a thing of the past by this point, but here we are. I wish game developers could get a clue regarding the camera. This point is soured even more by analog stick control system. Instead of using one of the sticks to manage the camera, they used the LS for movement and RS for weapon control. This left no way to easily control the camera. So, it ends up uncontrollable. The only thing you can do (and it only works at certain times) is press the left bumper button to reset the camera forward. Even still, the camera can very quickly change. When the camera moves, it's not a smooth flowing action. Instead, it moves in a quick cut. Because of this abrupt cut, you get briefly disoriented which requires determining where you are once again. This easily kills valuable time when you're in a battle.

Save Points

This game allows you to save anywhere, but only saves a single checkpoint. This means, if you want to load and restart from that checkpoint, you usually start over at the beginning of the level. It does not start you exactly where you saved. So, expect to have to redo a bunch of things to get back to where you actually wanted to start.

Character deaths

This is THE most annoying part of this game. When your character 'dies', an 'angelic' character comes down from the sky and picks you up and carts you off. This animation is not skippable. Instead, you have to wait through this torturously long scene each and every time you die. Other cinematics are skippable, this one is not. Whoever made this decision in the game should have their head examined.

Also, there is no point to dying as each and every time your character is 'reincarnated' with full health. Meaning, once you wait through the torturously long death scene, your character is reset and placed a distance away. The enemies you have done damage to remain damaged so you can finish the battle. They might as well have just given infinite health and skipped the death scene altogether.

Graphics

The graphics behind this game are good in places and poor in others. The cinematics look good, but are a bit long in places. It's good that they fully explain the story, but there are so many cinematics in this game that it really gets a bit old after a while. For me, cinematics should really be used only to move the story along in a major way. They should not be used for small story elements. The textures are reasonably high res, but the characters end up too small on the screen.

Sound

The music and effects worked, but didn't stand out. It wasn't exceptionally cinematic. The voice acting worked but would not win any awards. Some of the dialog is stilted and unnatural.

Overall

This game is somewhat enjoyable for a third person shooter. I found it to be more fun than Dead Space (which came out right around the same time as Too Human). For a leveling up system, though, BioShock still far exceeds this system for a third person shooter. If you're really wanting a quality third person shooter with an excellent leveling system, play BioShock. If you're looking for an RPG, I'd recommend either Oblivion or Knights of the Old Republic.

Score
  • Sound: 8/10 (best part of this game, keeps the suspense up)
  • Graphics: 8/10 (textures and figures are well done)
  • Bugginess: ?/10 (unrated)
  • Controls: 5/10 (LS bad choice for weapon control, no camera control)
  • Bang-To-Buck: 1/10 (rent or buy it used, don't pay full price)
  • Play Value: $25
  • Overall: 6.5/10 (serviceable, fun in places, controls are a drag, long death sequences)
Note: Play Value is the dollar amount this game is actually worth based on quality, play time and overall fun derived. It is not what a store will charge you.

Wednesday, December 31, 2008

Xbox 360 - Dead Space

Dead Space

My final review for 2008!

Parental Advisory: This game contains graphic violence and mature themes. Parental guidance is suggested.

As is expected from EA, this is standard third person shooter wrapped around an 'Alien' (movie) type story. What makes this one stand out? Nothing specific, but let's explore this game anyway.

Story

The story behind this shooter combines themes from Alien and Event Horizon to create this tale. You're a team sent to investigate what's happening on a floating scientific research station orbiting a planet. When you arrive at the station, bad things begin happening (expected). First, you almost crash into the station. Then, later, your ship explodes and you're stranded there.

As your character explores the station trying to bring the station back to life so you can leave, you find mutated Alien-esque creatures. Of course, you have to kill them.

Graphics

The 3D engine used here works quite well. The imagery and textures are very well done, if not a bit graphic. The lighting used is reminiscent of what's used in the Alien movies (lots of strobes, flashing lights, flourescent lights that flicker, etc).

Audio

The music and thematic elements swell when enemies arrive in the area. It is very cinematic in sound and the eerie sound effects add to the chill-factor. But, even as good as it sounds, it's not enough to save this mediocre title.

Gameplay & Controls

The controls work well enough through much of the game up until Chapter 4 (we'll get to that shortly) where the game completely breaks down.

The suit you are tasked to use has limited protection, but allows you to walk in zero gravity and has a small amount of air for vacuum space walks (nevermind the temperature issue in this game). Anyway, you start off with no guns and obtain them either as you find them (in containers) or you can buy them at the store.

Save Points

The save points are strewn throughout the levels attached to the wall (as if that makes any sense) and opens up to reveal a holographic save area. So, there are limited places where you can save. However, the save points do seem to be in convenient enough places that it's easy to save often. So, in this particular shooter, the save points aren't the issue.

Store

As you progress through killing aliens and opening containers, you will find various items including money, health, ammo and power nodes. Money allows you to buy things at the Stores in various places on the levels. The stores contain ammo, health, weapons, stasis replenishment and various other things. While you wander, you will also find schematics for new weapons and suits that you can buy. The idea that there is a store is ok, the way it's done sucks.

The problems with Dead Space

The problems with this game are many and varied. The primary problem with much of this game is that there is so little health on the levels that you're always one step away from dying. When you do find a store, the health is so expensive you have to practically give away all the money you've found just to get a small container of health. For example, you're lucky to have about 8000-9000 credits when you get to the store and a small container of health costs 1250. That price would be fine if there was abundant health on the levels, but there isn't.

Worse, as you progress through the levels, you end up finding more and more ammo and less and less health.... to the point at which, on level 4, that you don't find ANY health in any containers or after killing the aliens. This makes the game annoying at best.

Nodes

Again, here is another sore point. Nodes are used at work 'benches' throughout the various levels to upgrade your suit, weapons or abilities. The problem, again, is that there are so few nodes found on the levels, you really get no benefit out of the upgrades. Worse, at the workbench, the system forces you to waste nodes on useless node intersections just to get to an intersection that lets you upgrade. This is pointless and a waste. You find so few that you end up wasting over half of the nodes you find on worthless things.

Encounters

There are many times where the game continually throws alien after alien at you simply to use up your health and waste ammo. The encounters are not there to be a challenge because the weapons will eventually kill them. So, it's just a time, ammo and health waster. If the encounters were far less predictable and the weapons were far stronger, then I might feel less this way.

Map

The map is just plain annoying. At first, it seems like a cool idea to have this 3D holographic type map which shows your present level. Unfortunately, you can't leave it on while you walk as it prevents button presses. But, in order to find out where to go, you have to leave it on. So, you have to pray you don't get attacked while you have it open. You also end up having to waste time getting the map into the correct position so you can even see where you are and where you need to be.

Applying health

As you pick up containers of health, they are stored in your inventory. Your inventory is limited, so you will eventually run out of space, which is arbitrarily stupid. When you open your inventory to view it, the game continues to progress. So, the game does not pause and you continue to be attacked while the inventory is open and you try to apply more health.. which is, again, arbitrarily stupid. So, if you need to apply health during a battle, you do so at your own peril.

Level 4

Up until level 4, the game was pretty much a straight shooter with aliens jumping out at you from all over (at very predictable times). Through trial and error, you can work your way through the level by having the character die and then restarting the level. In fact, many sub-levels I had to do this just to try to figure out what the game wanted me to do.

However, after you traverse across the outside of the ship and make it across to the other side (without becoming asteroid smashed), you end up at a chair with a gun. Ok, so here's my BIGGEST gripe with this game. You're working your way through the levels as a typical shooter and here the game completely breaks that stride for a stupid chair based asteroid mini-game. Then, the mini-game starts you off with 85% hull integrity. Each asteroid reduces 8-10% hull integrity with each hit. So, you are tasked to blow up the asteroids and keep the hull safe while you wait for something to happen. That's fine, but the game starts throwing more and more and more (and even bigger) asteroids at you all over the screen. Not only do the big ones break up into smaller ones, like the old Asteroid game, they accelerate towards you faster and faster. In fact, it begins throwing so many at you so rapidly (while waiting), it's basically impossible to complete. All the while I'm thinking, "What the hell does it have to do with the game?".

To top that off, the gun has an 'overheat' mode that prevents you from firing 5-10 seconds at a time far too frequently. Ok, so what the point of this level is, I have no idea. It's not challenging, it's not fun. In fact, it's a stupid remake of an old Old OLD arcade game from the 70's which, in Dead Space, has no real point.

Worse, you've got your 'friend' chiming in saying 'Just hold them off for a little longer' or 'I'm almost done' or 'Keep it up for a little longer'. It's like, "Shut the eff up!" These little taunts are enough for me to take this game disk and run it through the shredder. There's nothing fun about being taunted while you're trying to concentrate on a near impossible task.

After all that, the gun controls don't perform well, there's no auto-targeting, you always way overshoot the mark and it seems to miss even when you actually are able to aim. Oh, and did I already ask.. What's the point to this Asteroid level?

Overall

This game has way too many problems to be fixable. Was this game even play tested? Did someone actually run this by human beings to find out if it was a passable game? These are the kinds of games that are throw-away commodities. This will be forgotten in less than a year and no one will want to play it. It will sit on Gamestop's used shelves and collect dust. Some random shmoe might buy one periodically to try it, but quickly return it in the 7 day grace for a full refund.

Score
  • Sound: 9/10 (best part of this game, keeps the suspense up)
  • Graphics: 9/10 (textures and figures are well done)
  • Bugginess: 10/10 (no bugs or major glitches found)
  • Controls: 6/10 (controls well enough until the Asteroids part)
  • Play Value: $10
  • Bang-To-Buck: 1/10 (if you must play this, rent it or buy it used)
  • Overall: 4/10 (inconsistent game play, tedious in places, predictable, not enough supplies)
Note, I would have given this game an even lower overall score, but the first 3 levels of the game were reasonably enjoyable. However, the Asteroids mini-game is so out-of-touch with the rest of this game, I no have no intention of finishing this game.

Happy New Year ... I'll see you in 2009.

Comments